Islam’s Greatest Contradictions
This is not a surface-level critique. This is a full-scale theological, historical, and logical takedown of the internal contradictions at the very core of Islam. If Islam were a building, these are the foundational cracks — and they are widening.
🔁 CONTRADICTION #1: "Islam Is Unchanging" — But Its Core Doctrine Keeps Evolving
"If Allah cannot be changed — why does Islamic doctrine keep evolving?"
Muhammad’s Islam (Islam 1.0): Raw, tribal, supremacist, centered around personal obedience to Muhammad. No sharia, no hadith books, no Sunni/Shia, no schools of law.
Islam 2025: Codified legal systems, sectarian divisions, contradictory hadiths, and PR sanitization.
Evolution = Contradiction. If Islam is perfect, it shouldn't mutate.
🧠 CONTRADICTION #2: The Law of Identity Destroyed
A thing is what it is. It cannot be what it is not.
If Muhammad’s Islam affirmed slavery, jihad, and subjugation of non-Muslims, and modern Islam denies these — then they cannot be the same religion.
If A = A, and B ≠ A, then B ≠ A.
📖 CONTRADICTION #3: The Bible Was Corrupted — But Allah Says It Wasn’t
Surah 5:47 — Christians must judge by the Gospel.
Surah 6:115 — "None can alter the words of Allah."
Surah 10:94 — Muhammad told to ask the People of the Book if in doubt.
Yet: Islamic theology claims the Bible is corrupt. That means Allah:
Endorsed a forgery.
Didn’t know it was corrupt.
Lied about its status.
All outcomes are fatal to Islam’s truth claims.
🕍 CONTRADICTION #4: Abraham, Moses, and Jesus Were Muslims?
If Abraham, Moses, and Jesus were Muslims — why does their recorded teaching look 100% non-Islamic?
No prayers toward Mecca.
No mention of the Kaaba.
No Ramadan, no Shahada, no five daily prayers.
Jesus was worshiped as divine by His followers from day one.
Islam retroactively claims the prophets — but their lives and messages contradict Islam entirely.
📉 CONTRADICTION #5: 124,000 Prophets — All Missing
Quran says a prophet was sent to every nation (Surah 16:36).
Yet the Quran only names 25 prophets — most from Jewish scriptures.
No historical trace of Muslim prophets in China, India, Rome, or Egypt.
Islam invented prophets after the fact — with no names, no teachings, no history.
⏳ CONTRADICTION #6: The 2600-Year Black Hole
Why would Allah allow the complete loss of all Islamic revelation for centuries until Muhammad?
From Ishmael (c. 1900 BC) to Muhammad (610 AD), Islam vanished.
No monotheism in Arabia, no record of revelation, no Islamic practices.
The Kaaba was a pagan shrine until Muhammad’s takeover.
That’s not divine continuity — it’s theological amnesia.
🔥 CONTRADICTION #7: Quran Preservation Myth
Bukhari 6.61.510: Uthman burned rival Qurans.
Aisha: Verses were lost (Muslim 2286).
Warsh vs. Hafs: Thousands of differences.
Early manuscripts don’t match today’s standard text.
If Allah promised to protect the Quran (Surah 15:9), He failed.
🕌 CONTRADICTION #8: Global Domination Prophecy Failed
Surah 61:9 — Islam will prevail over all religions.
Reality: Christianity is still larger. Muslim empires have fallen. Muslim nations are fractured.
If Allah guaranteed global domination, why is Islam divided, stagnant, and shrinking in influence?
❌ CONTRADICTION #9: Muhammad — Moral Example?
Married a 6-year-old (Bukhari 5133).
Took Zaynab, his adopted son’s wife.
Led offensive jihads, sanctioned slavery.
This is not morality — this is moral regression.
🧩 CONTRADICTION #10: Allah’s Nature
Guides whom He wills… and misleads others (Surah 14:4).
Calls Himself the best of deceivers (Surah 3:54).
Punishes those He misleads.
That’s not justice — it’s fatalism masked as faith.
🧱 FINAL COLLAPSE: Self-Destruction by Contradiction
If the earlier scriptures were preserved → Islam is unnecessary.
If they were corrupted → The Quran affirms forgeries.
If Muhammad's Islam is true → Modern Islam is false.
If modern Islam is true → Muhammad was not a prophet.
Either way…
Islam cancels itself.
🔚 Conclusion: The Contradictions Are Not Cosmetic — They Are Terminal
Islam claims to be the final, unchanging revelation of a perfect God.
But:
Its origin story contradicts history.
Its theology contradicts itself.
Its prophet contradicts morality.
Its scriptures contradict preservation.
Islam’s greatest contradictions aren’t hidden. They’re in the text.
And the deeper you dig, the more it collapses.
📍Final Question: If Allah didn’t make these mistakes — who did?
✅ Not God.
✅ Not prophets.
❌ Just men — trying to patch holes in a sinking ship.
No comments:
Post a Comment